The Ultimate Guide to Selling AI in 2025 (For Founders and Sales Reps)
A tactical guide for AI founders and sales reps on how to sell effectively in 2025 by focusing on specific use cases, avoiding enterprise traps, and building a repeatable sales motion that actually converts.
.png)
INTRO
Selling AI right now feels different than it did even a year ago. Buyers are curious, but they’re now also skeptical with all of the noise in the market. The old “AI for X” pitch just isn’t working anymore. In this post, I’ll walk you through what I’ve learned on the front lines selling AI to Fortune 500 companies and consulting with dozens of AI founders. If you’re a founder or a sales rep trying to cut through the noise and actually get deals done, this is your playbook.
WHAT YOU’LL LEARN
- Why most AI sales messaging fails in 2025
- How to define and target the right ICP
- The hidden risks of enterprise sales cycles
- How to structure outreach and trials that actually convert
- What founders can do today to land their first 5 to 10 customers
CONTEXT: WHY THIS MATTERS
AI is everywhere, but very few people know how to sell it well. The tools are powerful, but the market is flooded with lookalike products and generic messaging. Founders are wasting months chasing enterprise pilots that go nowhere. Sales reps are automating cold emails without first testing if their pitch even makes sense. The result? Everyone’s stuck in the same cycle: interest with no momentum. This guide is built to break that cycle.
WHAT’S BROKEN IN TODAY’S AI SALES STRATEGY
The “AI for X” Pitch Doesn’t Move People Anymore
A year ago, saying “we’re AI for job boards” or “AI for CRM” got attention. Now? Buyers tune it out. Everyone says they’re AI-powered. That alone doesn’t mean anything anymore.
Here’s the problem: when you pitch yourself like a flexible engine that can do a bunch of cool stuff, buyers assume you don’t really understand their business. And if they don’t see a clear, urgent reason to act now, they won’t.
Instead of saying, “We’re AI for e-commerce,” say something like: “We help marketplace platforms automatically detect fraud across 10,000+ daily transactions, using AI agents that monitor buyer-seller chat and flag risky behavior in real time.”
That’s the difference between being vague and being sharp. It gives your prospect something they can picture immediately and care about today.
Automation Tools Like Clay Only Work If Your Message Is Already Dialed In
A lot of founders and reps are using tools like Clay to send thousands of “custom” emails. But here’s the truth: if your cold email doesn’t work when you send it to ten people manually, it’s not going to magically start working when you send it to ten thousand people through automation.
Before scaling your outreach with tools, do this:
- Manually write and send 50 emails to your ideal customer profile (ICP).
- Track which subject lines, call-to-actions, and problem statements actually get replies.
- Once you find a combo that works, then use automation to scale it.
- IF IT IS NOT WORKING, DO NOT AUTOMATE IT. Keep testing new messaging.
Think of automation like gasoline. If your fire isn’t lit, it won’t help. Check out this guide for a detailed 1 hour walkthrough of how to create cold messaging that actually converts.
Founders Are Chasing Enterprise Customers Too Early
This one is especially painful. Big logos are tempting. Everyone wants to land JP Morgan or Google. But here’s what most founders don’t realize: enterprise companies are mostly exploring AI so they can learn what’s possible. Not so they can buy from you.
I talked to one bank where the internal AI team received over 250 internal project ideas during a hackathon. You know how many they approved to build this year? Two. And that’s with their own engineers, not an external vendor. So if you're an early-stage founder trying to sell to these companies, it’s important to understand what you're signing up for.
Even if they’re polite, even if they say “this is interesting,” it often means they’re going to take your pitch and try to build it internally. Or delay any real decision for 12 to 24 months. That’s a long time to wait for a maybe.
Instead, start with small to mid-sized companies. These businesses can move faster, take more risk, and give you real results within weeks or months. Your product will mature as you have actual users, you'll get real feedback from real users to build your roadmap, and you can build a rolodex of successful users and case studies that will quickly help you attract enterprise attention without putting your entire company's success dependent upon 1 potential customer.
Flexible AI Messaging Creates Confusion
When you tell a prospect, “we can do all kinds of things with AI,” you think you’re showing value. But from their side, it’s overwhelming. It feels like they have to figure out what problem you solve.
Instead, be direct. Be the expert who already understands their world and has built something just for them. If you’re reaching out to a high-volume e-commerce platform, talk about how you reduce refund abuse or detect fraud at scale. Don’t make them guess.
The Real Competition Is Often DIY, Not Other Vendors
A lot of founders think they’re competing with other AI startups. In reality, you’re often competing with the buyer’s own internal team. Many prospects would rather try to build something themselves than risk picking the wrong vendor and wasting budget.
You need to understand if they prefer to build in house, and if so, determine if/why building this in-house would cost more, take longer, or create risk. Don’t just pitch features. Make the case that working with you is the faster, safer path to a real business outcome. Onboarding with your tool which is ready to go will allow them to focus on other high-priority business impacting problems.
WHAT’S ACTUALLY WORKING IN 2025
Start with a Clear, Pain-First ICP
Your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) isn’t just a job title and company size. It’s the person who feels the pain your product solves the most.
Ask yourself:
- What actual pains are they having that could be solved with AI? (Not things they could do with AI, but problems they CURRENTLY have).
- What internal conversations are they already having about AI?
- What happens if they don’t solve this problem in the next 90 days? What about a year from now?
- What would your solution(s) actually mean to their business? Not just the people using the tool.
When you’ve defined that level of detail, your messaging becomes more specific, and your cold outreach lands much harder.
Direct-to-Consumer? Focus on Distribution and Frictionless Onboarding
If you’re building a Direct-to-Consumer AI product, your biggest advantage is how fast people can try your product and see value. A few things that are working right now:
- Build organic distribution through content. Post regularly on LinkedIn, YouTube, or TikTok with real examples and results.
- Affiliate Marketing - finding creators in your space that will make content about your product. (Great example here from a founder that grew to $10M ARR)
- Remove friction from onboarding. Let people try your product without a credit card (for products under $100/month). Make it easy to connect their accounts through SSO/Email sign in.
- Offer referral incentives. One example is an AI email tool that gives users $150 in credit for referring new customers. That kind of built-in growth loop rewards your most loyal customers.
In B2B, Value Needs to Show Up Fast
If you’re selling to a business and running trials or proof-of-concepts, the clock is ticking from day one. Buyers are flooded with tools and possibilities right now. You have maybe 30 to 60 days to show real value or they’ll move on (or 'keep you posted').
Here’s how to stand out:
- Understand the organizations approach to testing and purchasing AI products BEFORE starting a trial
- How have they already adopted AI? What is required to bring a new vendor in? etc...
- Define success metrics before the trial starts.
- Limit your proof-of-concept to one or two specific use cases.
- Set up the tool live with the customer to ensure its set up properly and that they can use it as it was intended.
If your product requires too much upfront work, they’ll deprioritize it the second another fire pops up.
How to Open Sales Conversations That Don’t Get Stuck
Almost every buyer is willing to talk about AI from credible sources. But very few are ready to buy right now unless they have a serious pain or problem they need solved.
So once you have a conversation secured, how do you open it up?
Start like this:
“Hey, I know a lot of companies are evaluating AI right now. I’m curious, how are you and your team thinking about this over the next year or two?”
What problems are they trying to address with AI? Why are they addressing those problems now? Have they tried to solve them before without AI? etc....
This shifts the conversation away from you and toward their goals.
Real Example: The Founder Who Got It Right
One of the founders I’ve worked with recently was selling an AI agent for e-commerce platforms. At first, they were pitching every type of online/e-commerce store. They used Clay to send over a thousand emails. Got two replies. Zero meetings.
We narrowed their focus to marketplace-style platforms. Places that have high volume and rely on buyer-seller interactions. We rewrote their messaging to say:
“We’ve built AI agents specifically for marketplaces that process 10,000 or more transactions a day. Our system monitors chat between buyers and sellers, flags fraud automatically, and reduces manual work for your support team.”
They booked three meetings in one morning with that message.
That’s the power of getting specific. It doesn’t just sound better. It resonates with executives and sets the tone for a highly productive conversation.
FAQ
Q: Why aren’t enterprise buyers purchasing more AI tools?
A: Many are building in-house and don’t want to risk picking the wrong vendor. Their review cycles are long and heavily regulated.
Q: What’s the fastest way for a founder to get traction?
A: Start with SMBs, define a painful use case, and manually reach out with a very specific offer.
Q: Should I use Clay or other AI tools for outreach?
A: Yes, but only after manually validating your message and ideal customer. Automation without clarity just burns leads.
Q: How long should a trial or POC last?
A: Ideally 30 to 60 days, with clear goals and simple onboarding. Any longer and momentum dies.
Q: What’s a good way to open AI sales calls?
A: Ask how they’re thinking about AI over the next 12 to 24 months. Then connect their goals to your specific solution.
→ If you’re a founder trying to build your first repeatable sales motion, join our Founder-Led Sales Accelerator. Learn how to build a sustainable sales motion from scratch (in weeks), how to book real meetings with real buyers, and how to scale once your message lands.
TL;DR
- “AI for X” pitches are dead. Be specific about the problem you solve. Understand if your prospect is even experiencing a problem first.
- In almost all cases you shouldn't waste time selling to enterprise companies too early. Start with SMBs.
- Tools like Clay only work once your message is tested and working.
- Run short trials with defined goals to show value quickly.
- Focus your outreach on real pain points and talk like a human.